Why do HIV prevention programmes fail to reach at risk men?
The case of voluntary male medical circumcision roll out in South Africa
A promising HIV prevention strategy aimed specifically at young men is voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC), as men who have been medically circumcised are 60% less likely to contract HIV through male to female vaginal sex. The World Health Organization and the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS have recommended that 80% of men, aged 15 to 49 years old undergo circumcision by the end of 2016. Should these targets be met, the VMMC intervention should avert more than 1 million new HIV infections by the year 2025. Furthering its appeal, VMMC is a once off procedure and is fairly cost effective from a health systems standpoint. The possibility of a seemingly simple and effective HIV prevention offered by VMMC has created a stir of optimism in the field of HIV prevention.
But how widespread has the uptake of VMMC been? More importantly, have the most at risk young men been reached? A large household study in KwaZulu-Natal revealed:
- Only 32% of men had undergone VMMC by 2015 and half of them were younger than 22 years old.
- These men came from households with higher incomes and have acquired higher levels of formal schooling than their uncircumcised counterparts.
- Additionally, men who were circumcised engaged in fewer HIV risk behaviours than uncircumcised men; they also had fewer sexual partners over their lifetime.
- They were more likely to use a condom after consuming alcohol, more likely to use a condom consistently at first sex, and more likely to use a condom with their most recent partner and in general in the previous year.
What this data points to is that the most economically and socially marginalised men who are also most at risk for contracting HIV have not become involved in the VMMC programme. This highlights the general failure of HIV prevention programmes to attract and reduce – risk of the men who are most at risk for contracting and transmitting HIV. This is not the first time biomedical HIV prevention programmes in South Africa have failed to impact key populations. Many types of microbicides targeting vulnerable women have failed to reduce HIV incidence. Other nonsuccesses include low levels of condom use and poor ART adherence. The failure of interventions and programmes that in strictly biomedical terms, should be highly effective can be attributed to the failure to consider the complex social processes that influence the public reception of such HIV prevention techniques.
It is critical that policy makers consider the impact of social processes on biomedical HIV prevention programmes. One such social issue, particularly pertinent to the VMMC programme, is traditional masculine identities. Traditional masculinities have been shown to hamper men’s access to HIV services, and may be one of the root causes of young men’s self-exclusion from VMMC uptake. In the simplest of terms many men perceive VMMC as a challenge to their masculinity. To effectively reach young men HIV services need to be made more ‘male friendly’ and more responsive to men’s lack of efficacy in seeking health care.
The following recommendations have previously been put forward to increase men’s participation in HIV prevention and treatment services:
- Language around HIV campaigns needs to be directed at the male gendered identities.
- Safe social spaces should exist where men can collectively discuss the challenges they are facing in accessing HIV services.
- HIV services should be decentralized and moved to spaces that are not predominantly viewed as female (such as hospitals and clinics).
- Discussions should be held at community level about masculine identities and how these create opportunities and barriers to the men’s health seeking behaviour.
- The final recommendation suggests that the partners of targeted men should be involved in encouraging men to undergo circumcision.
It must be reiterated that biomedical prevention programmes such as VMMC, will only be successful if the social processes around HIV are taken cognisant of when designing the roll out of HIV prevention programmes.
While VMMC is viewed as one of the most important methods to prevent HIV, its success will always be limited if those responsible for its roll out do not consider the social and contextual factors influencing the uptake of VMMC. Only then will we be able to rectify the current pitfalls that the VMMC campaign has encountered and thereby stand a better chance of reaching the targets set out by experts in the field.
- Masculinity as a barrier to men’s use of HIV services in Zimbabwe
- Barriers and facilitators to the uptake of voluntary medical male circumcision among adolescent boys in KwaZulu–Natal, South Africa >
- Voluntary medical male circumcision – considerations for policy and practice >
- Beyond ‘working with men and boys’: (re)defining, challenging and transforming masculinities in sexuality and health programmes and policy >
- ‘Men value their dignity': Securing respect and identity construction in urban informal settlements in South Africa >
HEARD researchers are live at the @AIDSImpact conference currently underway in Cape Town, South Africa. We’ll be sharing updates from their research presentations and discussions around key populations, health systems, HIV prevention and health financing. Tweet #AIDSImpact Tweets by HEARD_UKZN
Dr Bereket Yakob Yota, a recent graduate of HEARD’s PhD Programme at UKZN has been appointed as a visiting scientist at the prestigious Harvard T.H Chan School of Public Health. Dr Yota who graduated with a PhD at the University of KwaZulu Natal in 2016, has been selected to contribute to the ...>>
HEARD recently hosted the second in a series of high-level retreats around domestic financing and prioritisation of health under the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, better known as SDGs. The meeting took place at the Thanda Private Game Reserve in Hluhluwe, South Africa between 28 ...>>
December 1 marked World AIDS Day. A brief moment reflection our recent achievements in the fight against HIV and AIDS point to some significant victories. Globally, we have more scientific knowledge on how the virus is transmitted with prevention and treatment options being tailored to suit ...>>
Media release: HEARD embarks on an extensive research project on young key populations in SADC countries
HEARD embarks on an extensive research project on young key populations in SADC countries, in collaboration with the United Nations Development Programme and African Men for Sexual Health and Rights Durban, South Africa | 1 December 2016 HEARD has successfully obtained a large research grant to ...>>
ARV treatment on the rise, but UN urges urgent action as thousands of young women continue to be infected with HIV. The number of HIV-infected people taking anti-retroviral (ARV) medicine has doubled in just five years, the United Nations said while highlighting high infection rates among young ...>>
HEARD’s Scholarship Programme aims to emphasise the mastery of quantitative and qualitative methods for understanding policy problems and for devising, evaluating and/or implementing policy solutions. The aim of providing PhD scholarships is to produce expertly qualified graduates to advise or ...>>
Frank Tanser shares results from a population-based cohort in rural KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa on the application of geospatial analyses to reveal targets for intervention
Frank Tanser an infectious disease epidemiologist with specialist expertise in geographical information systems technology, shares results from a population-based cohort in rural KZN, on the application of geospatial analyses to reveal targets for intervention. About the speaker: Frank Tanser ...>>
It is now possible for antiretroviral therapy (ART) to reduce viral load of HIV to the point where an infected person is no longer, or much less, infectious to others. As a result, ‘treatment as prevention’ has become the cornerstone of UNAIDS’s post-2015 global strategy to end AIDS by 2030. As ...>>
HEARD’s research director Dr Govender was recently awarded a National Research Foundation and Swedish Foundation for International Cooperation in Research and Higher Education research capacity building grant to forge systematic research on health systems and HIV in Eastern and Southern ...>>